Tuesday, 16 July 2024

THE LAMENTABLE LAMMY

Tom Harris who wrote this is a former Labour MP so deserves to be listened to. It is a damning indictment of the choice of Lammy.



Remarks by the Republican nominee for vice-president have just made life more difficult for our Foreign Secretary, David Lammy.

Senator JD Vance of Ohio last week suggested that the first Islamist state to obtain nuclear weapons was not Iran or even Pakistan– it was the UK. The remarks elicited some laughter from his audience, as they were intended to. Let us not start fretting that the man likely to be just one heartbeat away from the Oval Office from January genuinely believes that Britain has been captured by extremists determined to impose Sharia Law on its citizens or strike with mighty vengeance those who dishonour the Prophet.

But it is a signal that Britain needs to start addressing the prospect of Trump 2.0. The task will be fraught and challenging. People of courage, principle and sensitivity will be required for the task. 

Enter David Lammy.

Even before the attempted assassination of Donald Trump at the weekend, there were already big question marks over Keir Starmer’s decision to appoint Lammy to one of the four great offices of state, in charge of Britain’s relationship with the rest of the world.

But events in the US have brought renewed focus on some historic Tweets that the Tottenham MP ill-advisedly published when he was in opposition. And they raise serious question marks over Lammy judgment and his ability to do the job he has been in for less than a fortnight.

Most concerning is Lammy’s decision, in 2019, to mock Trump for complaining about how he was being treated by his political opponents. “4 US presidents have been assassinated snowflake”, he said on Twitter. While Lammy might claim today that he would not have made the crass comment had he known that Trump would actually become the target of a gunman, he said himself that four presidents have been murdered in office: gun violence is part of American culture and British politicians really shouldn’t tempt fate publicly.

Under the last Labour government, Lammy was a supporter of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown in their premierships, voting to renew Britain’s independent nuclear deterrent while he was collecting a salary as a minister. 

Then, in opposition, he supported Jeremy Corbyn, a man whom Lammy knew well – certainly well enough to know that he was a unilateralist, a self-declared friend of Hamas Islamist terrorists and had been a consistent critic of the European Union for decades. In fact, with an In/Out referendum on Britain’s EU membership looming, Lammy chose to nominate Corbyn – the only anti-EU candidate in the field – to be leader of the Labour Party, despite Lammy’s claims before and since that he was a dyed-in-the-wool supporter of Remain.

A year later, Lammy announced that, his previous voting record notwithstanding, his Christian faith would now not allow him to vote for the renewal of Trident. And a few years after that, with Corbyn safely suspended from the party and Keir Starmer installed as party leader, he decided that retaining Trident was “paramount” after all.

In 2017, Lammy praised Corbyn’s leader’s speech at Labour conference as “bloody brilliant” (it wasn’t) and predicted that Corbyn “is heading to Number 10”. But by 2021, Lammy had changed tunes again, expressing regret that he’d nominated Corbyn and insisting that, contrary to what he himself had said publicly, he had never believed Corbyn would ever become prime minister.

Lammy’s historic remarks about President Trump are just another reminder of his poor judgment. Describing the leader of the free world as “a neo-Nazi-sympathising sociopath” and a “tyrant in a toupée” will undoubtedly have achieved what Lammy wanted to do at the time – elicit praise from Labour activists and members – but they were not the remarks of a serious politician, let alone a statesman, and certainly not a future Foreign Secretary.

Lammy, perhaps rather optimistically, counts Senator Vance as a friend, having praised his autobiographical discourse on America’s working classes, “Hillbilly Elegy” while – inevitably – drawing parallels with his own upbringing in London.

But whether the two men’s “friendship” is confected or not, it will always take second place to Vance’s loyalty to Trump. It would be naïve in the extreme to suggest that relations between the next Trump administration and the Starmer government would not be even slightly handicapped by the fact that the Foreign Secretary has used such insultingly absurd language to describe the president. Or perhaps Lammy has judged that Trump is the kind of guy who never holds a grudge?

The triumph of the Trump/Vance ticket in November would present an existential crisis for Nato and for Ukraine, and would force the Foreign Office to do what it does best: use every millilitre of diplomatic nous it possesses to ensure that Britain’s interests do not suffer – or at least suffer as little as possible – in the new Trump era. Keir Starmer, knowing it was at least possible that the 45th president might become the 47th, appointed to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office a man he knew had called Trump a neo-Nazi.

Judgment matters. We should be able to expect those who lead us to measure their words and their criticism, even at the risk of disappointing their audiences. Some things are more important than personal media profile. If the Foreign Secretary doesn’t realise that, Britain will pay the price

19 comments:

  1. Still no comments from The Dame's loyal courtiers . Could it be that the sophisticated residents of Kensington do not share her correspondent's low opinion of our new Foreign Secretary ? Or is 'The Ton' withholding judgement until we see how Lammy deals with getting the UK out of the diplomatic Palestine shaped hole that Sir Keir managed to drop us into in his initial unguarded comments last October ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fly On The Wall20 July 2024 at 22:30

      I have watched Lammy closely in the last 18 months at social events eg the Clevedon Literary Festival, where he spoke. And I have formed a very definite opinion. He is clever. He is able. He is conflicted by his origins and is still struggling to feel that he is "accepted". But my major concern is the answer to the question: Will he cope? Will the trappings of Office go to his head? I think they will. This will distort his judgement and sacrifice his authority and leadership

      Delete
    2. An intelligent, capable black man or woman should never(and rarely is) conflicted by background or acceptability. Time he grew up.

      Delete
    3. What a load of rubbish!

      DL is NOT at all conflicted about his background. He is English as he mades 100% clear in this YouTube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JclPuFjt7GU

      Delete
  2. Lammy would struggle to exit a large paper bag based on his embarrassing session on Mastermind. Why go on a programme like that knowing that you are so bereft of any form of general knowledge. A 10 year old would have had the answers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think anyone of any sophistication would know that Lammy is well above his pay grade and not waste energy commenting

    ReplyDelete
  4. Green Party MP Ellie Chowns asks foreign secretary David Lammy if he would stop selling arms to Israel https://www.tiktok.com/@empowerpalestinea/video/7394524421110697249

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. David Lammy slams Israeli minister who argued that starving the people of Gaza may be ‘moral’ way to get hostages released

      Delete
    2. Foreign Secretary ‘appalled’ after 80 killed in Israeli strike on Gaza school. David Lammy said Hamas must stop endangering civilians and Israel must comply with international humanitarian law.

      Delete
  5. In an article in The Observer, David Lammy set out Labour’s early approach to Israel which amounted to asking them to rein in their settlers in the West Bank and regime change in Gaza. Lammy praised the Biden Administration’s approach to Palestine and refered to the genocide as “humanitarian suffering in Gaza.” https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/dec/09/david-lammy-labour-oppose-expulsions-palestinians-bar-violent-settlers-uk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. David Lammy calls on Hezbollah to 'cease their attacks' after rocket strike on Israeli-controlled Golan Heights as Foreign Secretary admits he's 'deeply concerned' about Middle East conflict escalating | Daily Mail

      Delete
    2. Abdul? Someone called Lammy say we stop bombing Zionist pigs and their kids. We stop? Who is this man?

      Delete
    3. Foreign Secretary condemns Hezbollah rocket strike that killed 12 youngsters | Jewish News

      Delete
  6. David Lammy confirms Labour has DITCHED its plans to recognise a Palestinian state. Labour will instead delay recognition indefinitely, making it conditional on Israel feeling "safe and secure" as part of a "credible" and "viable" peace process. https://x.com/LeftieStats/status/1818241569691963547

    ReplyDelete
  7. Will an American tell us who we can (and can’t) have as our UK Foreign Secretary?

    If Donald Trump returns to the White House, then another restoration has been predicted to soon follow. Former US Ambassador Woody Johnson has warned, Donald Trump won't forget that David Lammy called him a racist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don’t tell us what to do Donald!

      Delete
    2. We are tough guys Donald and we don't need you when the Chinese invade....idiot!

      Delete
    3. Can the sender of the very recent comment on Lammy please resend it was deleted in error

      Delete
  8. Lammy and Donald were at dinner together last night https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13897669/Sir-Keir-Starmer-David-Lammy-called-President-Trump-woman-hating-neo-Nazi-sympathizing-sociopath-meet-two-hour-dinner-Trump-Tower.html

    ReplyDelete

Comments are your responsibility. Anyone posting inappropriate comments shall have their comment removed and will be banned from posting in future. Your IP address may also be recorded and reported. Persistent abuse shall mean comments will be severely restricted in future.